“All that glisters is not gold; Often have you heard that told: Many a man his life has sold But my outside to behold: Gilded tombs do worms enfold Had you been as wise as bold, Your in limbs, in judgment old, Your answer had not been in'scroll'd Fare you well: your suit is cold.' Cold, indeed, and labour lost: Then, farewell, heat and welcome, frost!” ― William Shakespeare, The Merchant of Venice
The Gilded Age, a term coined by Mark Twain to describe a society in which all was not as perfect as it seemed, occurred in the United States in the late 1800's. The era saw a radical shift in American culture as the economy transformed from an agrarian to industrial society. Marked by corruption and greed, the Gilded Age was also a time of reform. It also marked the entrance of the United States into the global market.
After the conclusion of the Civil War, the United States had to come to grips with new social and political realities caused by the abolition of slavery and the integration of free African Americans on a large scale. For information about the Reconstruction and the presidencies from Lincoln to Hayes, visit The Reconstruction. The turbulence of the Reconstruction was a harbinger of the political turmoil to come.
President James A. Garfield (March 5, 1881 – September 19, 1881)
Garfield's assassination at the hands of Charles Guiteau inadvertently led to political reform. Prior to his death, it was common for political positions to be awarded as a bonus for supporting a particular candidate or official (spoils system, Andrew Jackson). The Pendleton Civil Service Act was passed in 1883 to eliminate the spoils system. It stipulated that government employees should be hired only as a result of merit, and fired only as a consequence of poor work performance.
During the time in which Garfield and Arthur occupied the positions of president and vice president, the Republican party was deeply divided over the issue of the spoils system, among other things. The Stalwarts were headed by Senator Roscoe Conkling, and they considered themselves to be traditionalists who were in favor of the quid pro quo system. Prior to Arthur serving as Vice President under Garfield, he had been appointed to the position of Collector of the Port of New York. While in this position, he used his influence to appoint Conkling's supporters to political positions. Eventually, he was removed from office by President Hayes who accused him of corruption. Arthur's addition to the ticket was an attempt to garner the support of the Stalwart Republicans for Garfield. The Stalwarts favored Ulysses S. Grant running for a third term of office rather than Garfield.Geographically, the majority of Stalwarts came from southern regions, and often espoused positions similar to the Democrats who had the majority of the power there. This led to competition both within and outside of the Republican party. Stalwarts were opposed within the Republican party by the Half-Breeds, political moderates who were in favor of civil service reform. Garfield was a Half-Breed and Arthur was a Stalwart. Nevertheless, after Garfield's assassination, Arthur supported political reform against his own faction's interests.
President Grover Cleveland [22nd (1885-1889) and 24th (1894-1897)]
Mugwumps and the Blaine Truth
In the election of 1884, the popular Republican senator from Maine, James Blaine, faced off against his Democratic challenger, Grover Cleveland. Chester Arthur. despite suffering from the kidney disease which would eventually kill him, cast his lot into the election, but he found no support among his own party. The election was extremely acrimonious, devolving into personal attacks. Cleveland had an illegitimate child whom he not only acknowledged and supported, but his Republican opponents used that fact to raise questions about his character. The Republican candidate, on the other hand, had engaged in underhanded business dealings with the implication being that he had used his office to profit. The race was too close to measure until toward the end of the campaign trail, Blaine became associated with bigotry against immigrants and lost their support.
The belief that Blaine was corrupt caused an enormous amount of dissension in an already factionalized party. Some Republicans felt that they could not, in good conscience, support their party's candidate. These politicians, named by the media as "mugwumps" were seen as party traitors because they openly supported Cleveland for president.
Cleveland's Second Term
Immediately prior to to Grover Cleveland's second term in office, his wife, Caroline died of tuberculosis. Cleveland's victory, therefore, was more a result of the public concern over high tariffs than it was the result of any stirring campaign promises of his own. Unfortunately for him, the economic policies of the previous administration led to an economic collapse precipitated by the failure of the Reading Railroad (see Panic of 1893 below). Despite the fact that this was the worst economic collapse in the young country's history, Cleveland failed to respond while unemployment skyrocketed to almost 20% nationwide and up to 40% regionally. His laissez faire approach to government was influenced by Social Darwinism and the belief that "fluctuations" were a natural part of the market.
I do not believe that the power and duty of the General Government ought to be extended to the relief of individual suffering which is in no manner properly related to the public service or benefit. A prevalent tendency to disregard the limited mission of this power and duty should, I think, be steadfastly resisted, to the end that the lesson should be constantly enforced that though the people support the Government the Government should not support the people. ~Grover Cleveland
Cleveland's second term also marked the first time when federal troops were used to suppress dissent. Federal troops were sent in to Pullman, Illinois to stop striking workers at all costs, leading to violence on the part of the workers and the murder of civilians on the part of the troops.
Cleveland and Race and Culture
Cleveland's social opinions related to foreign policy were far more liberal than his domestic viewpoints. He was opposed to the vote for both women and Blacks, and refused to protect the vote for the latter by addressing racist and exclusionary laws in the south. He saw Blacks as fundamentally inferior, and was opposed to efforts to integrate schools and eliminate cultural boundaries. He adopted a paternalistic attitude toward Native American people, believing that their culture needed to be destroyed in order for them to move forward.
Cleveland's position on Chinese immigrants was a bit more complex. Initially, he expressed outrage and horror at the atrocities committed against Chinese immigrants. Nevertheless, he eventually came to the conclusion that the Chinese culture was incompatible with US culture and signed the Scott Act of 1888 into law.
Massacre of Chinese Workers, Rock Springs Wyoming, 1885
When Benjamin Harrison was elected to office, restoring the Republican dynasty, many saw it as a mandate from the American people to enact economic reforms. Harrison, although politically savvy and generally forward thinking for his era, was not a personable man. As a result, support for him and his policies was often lukewarm. He failed to win reelection after his 4 year term.
Explore the links at this site to learn about his life and domestic and foreign policies
The McKinley Tariff Act and the Sherman Silver Act were quid pro quo legislation which had a profound impact on the US economy. Harrison was a protectionist who believed that the only way to preserve the economy was to place exorbitant fees on imports. To ensure support for the imposition of tariffs, Harrison negotiated with western representatives and agreed to support a silver standard for the US economy that would benefit the western silver mines.
Agitation for action on the silver question was intense by 1890. Farmers were straining under growing debt and sharply falling prices. Western mining interests were anxious for a ready market for their silver and exerted pressure on Congress. Western voices were much stronger with the recent addition of Idaho, Montana, Washington, Wyoming and the Dakotas to the Union.
The Sherman Silver Purchase Act was part of a broader compromise. The Democrats gave their support to the highly protective McKinley Tariff in return for Republican votes for silver.
The Sherman Silver Purchase Act provided for the following:
The Treasury would purchase 4.5 million ounces (or 281,250 pounds) of silver each month at market rates
The Treasury would issue notes redeemable in either gold or silver.
The planned government purchases amounted to almost the total monthly output from the mines. However, the increased supply of silver drove down the price. Many mine operators in the West tried to reduce expenses by cutting the miners' wages. Labor unrest and sporadic violence followed.
As the price of silver continued to decline, holders of the government notes understandably redeemed them for gold rather than silver. The result of the growing disparity between the two metals was the depletion of the U.S. gold reserves, an event that played prominently during the Panic of 1893, following which Congress repealed the Sherman Silver Purchase Act.http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h762.html
Sherman Anti-Trust Act
The Billion Dollar Congress and the Panic of 1893
The election of 1888 saw the Republicans gain control of both the House and the Senate, and this new unilateral control removed any obstruction to the economic policies enacted under Harrison. Called the "Billion Dollar Congress," the legislature approved a variety of spending increases. This plus the disastrous Silver Act depleted the nation's gold reserves and led to a period of economic depression.